Table of Contents
When I first started writing and publishing fiction, which was when I first encountered editors, the two pieces of punctuation I struggled the most with were hyphens and commas. Now an editor myself, I’ve noticed that commas mystify many authors, so here is a short guide to using them.
First, a few disclaimers: 1) my knowledge of commas is informed by The Chicago Manual of Style 17th edition, 2) as I mentioned in another blog post, style rules are largely subjective, and 3) this article does not cover every use of the comma. Nevertheless, the below guidelines will steer you in the right direction.
The Purpose of Commas
Specifically, the purpose of commas is to separate ideas. Commas also create a little pause for the reader, so you don’t want to overuse them. Instead, use commas in the following ways:
- Place them according to convention so that your reader doesn’t get caught off guard.
- Use them to separate parts of sentences so that your reader doesn’t get confused.
- Use them to emphasize a word or phrase with that little pause.
It might be helpful to think of this pause effect in relation to other punctuation. For example, a period also creates a pause, but it is a much larger pause than with the comma.
Common Situations in Which to Use Commas
Between Independent Clauses in a Compound Sentence
The simplest way I can explain an independent clause is that it can stand on its own. At minimum, it has a subject and a verb, and it can be its own sentence. Examples:
- John screamed.
- She ran home after school.
- His socks were on backward.
If you have two independent clauses in the same sentence, you will need a comma and a conjunction (a word like and, but, or so) between them. Examples:
- John screamed, and Amy put her hands over her ears.
- She ran home after school, and her mother asked her why.
- His socks were on backward, and he didn’t notice.
You do not need a comma between an independent clause and a dependent clause, which is a part of a sentence that cannot stand on its own. Examples (dependent clause italicized):
- Amy put her hands over her ears because John screamed.
- Her mother asked her why she ran home after school.
- He didn’t notice that his socks were on backward.
Between Some Adjectives
When using multiple adjectives to describe one item, you sometimes need commas between them. This can get confusing, but the rule of thumb is that if you could put and between the adjectives, you need a comma. Another way to think about it is if you switched the adjectives around, would it still sound right? If it would not sound right switched around, you don’t need a comma.
As an example, you don’t need a comma if you are describing a big orange cat because you would not say an orange big cat. This is because in English, we have a conventional order of adjectives (this is a good article about that). I don’t know if it’s actually productive to memorize this order, so I’m not going to get into it here, but it is helpful to know that if adjectives belong to the same category such as color, size, material, etc., you need commas between them, and if they belong to a different category, you don’t.
- Her curly red hair bounced free from the tie.
- His ugly, uncomfortable cotton uniform made him sad.
- The scary huge green fleshy alien stared down at her with its teeny-tiny black eyes.
Between Items in a Series
When you are listing items in a sentence, you need commas between them. Depending on which style guide you are following, you will format it with or without the Oxford comma (whichever you do, do it consistently).
With the Oxford comma: She loved English, science, and math.
Without the Oxford comma: She loved English, science and math.
- She played soccer, football and basketball.
- The doctor was courteous, well-spoken, and kind.
- His favorite games were chess, checkers and Monopoly.
- She ran upstairs, took her shoes off, and got into bed.
To Set off Part of a Sentence That Isn’t Strictly Necessary to the Sentence’s Meaning
The technical term for this is restrictive versus nonrestrictive, where restrictive means that if you removed the item from the sentence, the sentence would be less clear. If an item is nonrestrictive, i.e. you could remove it without making the sentence less clear, it should be set off by a comma or commas—two if it is in the middle of the sentence and one if it is not.
- Cindy, who had blond hair, raised her hand.
- Parts of the newspaper The New York Times are behind a pay wall.
A Final Word
I have only listed a few comma situations in this post, and that is because I did not want to list the most subjective ones. Ultimately, it is up to you, the writer, to choose how to use commas in your work.
That being said, it is best to know a rule before you break it. This way, your style can be deliberate and informed as opposed to coming off amateurish or as if you’ve made unintentional mistakes.
For learning more about commas, I recommend the following resources:
- The Chicago Manual of Style Online (paid subscription)
- Perfect English Grammar: The Indispensable Guide to Excellent Writing and Speaking by Grant Barrett (in Kindle Unlimited at the time of this writing)
- Punctuation Mastery by Shani Raja (Udemy course)
If there is a comma situation that confuses you but that I didn’t cover in this post, please let me know what it is in the comments.